Die assembly#
With gdsfactory you can easily go from a simple Component, to a Component with many components inside.
In the same way that you need to Layout for DRC (Design Rule Check) clean devices, you have to layout obeying the Design for Test (DFT) and Design for Packaging rules.
Design for test#
To measure your chips after fabrication you need to decide your test configurations. This includes Design For Testing Rules like:
Individual input and output fibers
versusfiber array
. You can useadd_fiber_array
for easier testing and higher throughput, oradd_fiber_single
for the flexibility of single fibers.Fiber array pitch (127um or 250um) if using a fiber array.
Pad pitch for DC and RF high speed probes (100, 125, 150, 200um). Probe configuration (GSG, GS …)
Test layout for DC, RF and optical fibers.
from functools import partial
import gdsfactory as gf
gf.config.rich_output()
Pack#
Lets start with a resistance sweep, where you change the resistance width to measure sheet resistance.
def add_resistance_sweep_info(c):
c.info["doe"] = "resistance_sweep"
c.info["analysis"] = "[iv_resistance]"
c.info["analysis_parameters"] = "[{}]"
c.info["ports_electrical"] = 2
c.info["ports_optical"] = 0
return c
sweep = [gf.components.resistance_sheet(width=width) for width in [1, 10, 50]]
sweep_with_info = [add_resistance_sweep_info(c) for c in sweep]
m = gf.pack(sweep_with_info)
c = m[0]
c.draw_ports()
c.pprint_ports()
c.plot()
┏━━━━━━━━┳━━━━━━━┳━━━━━━━━━━━━━┳━━━━━━━━━━━━━┳━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━┳━━━━━━━━━━━━┓ ┃ name ┃ width ┃ orientation ┃ layer ┃ center ┃ port_type ┃ ┡━━━━━━━━╇━━━━━━━╇━━━━━━━━━━━━━╇━━━━━━━━━━━━━╇━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━╇━━━━━━━━━━━━┩ │ 0_pad1 │ 50.0 │ 270.0 │ MTOP (49/0) │ (30.05, 5.05) │ electrical │ │ 0_pad2 │ 50.0 │ 270.0 │ MTOP (49/0) │ (130.05, 5.05) │ electrical │ │ 1_pad1 │ 50.0 │ 270.0 │ MTOP (49/0) │ (30.05, 65.05) │ electrical │ │ 1_pad2 │ 50.0 │ 270.0 │ MTOP (49/0) │ (130.05, 65.05) │ electrical │ │ 2_pad1 │ 50.0 │ 270.0 │ MTOP (49/0) │ (30.05, 125.05) │ electrical │ │ 2_pad2 │ 50.0 │ 270.0 │ MTOP (49/0) │ (130.05, 125.05) │ electrical │ └────────┴───────┴─────────────┴─────────────┴──────────────────┴────────────┘
sweep_with_info[0].info
Info(
resistance=0,
doe='resistance_sweep',
analysis='[iv_resistance]',
analysis_parameters='[{}]',
ports_electrical=2,
ports_optical=0
)
Then we add spirals with different lengths to measure waveguide propagation loss. You can use both fiber array or single fiber.
@gf.cell
def spiral_gc(**kwargs):
"""Returns spiral with Grating Couplers."""
c = gf.components.spiral(**kwargs)
c = gf.routing.add_fiber_array(c)
c.info["doe"] = "spirals_sc" # strip Cband spirals
c.info["measurement"] = "optical_spectrum"
c.info["analysis"] = "[power_envelope]"
c.info["analysis_parameters"] = "[]"
c.info["ports_optical"] = 4
c.info["ports_electrical"] = 0
c.info.update(kwargs)
return c
c = spiral_gc(length=100)
c.plot()
c.info
Info(
length=100,
doe='spirals_sc',
measurement='optical_spectrum',
analysis='[power_envelope]',
analysis_parameters='[]',
ports_optical=4,
ports_electrical=0
)
sweep = [spiral_gc(length=length) for length in [100, 200, 300]]
m = gf.pack(sweep)
c = m[0]
c.plot()
You can also add some physical labels that will be fabricated.
For example you can add prefix S
at the north-center
of each spiral using text_rectangular
which is DRC clean and anchored on nc
(north-center)
text_metal = partial(gf.components.text_rectangular_multi_layer, layers=("M1",))
m = gf.pack(sweep, text=text_metal, text_anchors=("cw",), text_prefix="s")
c = m[0]
c.show()
c.plot()
Grid#
You can also pack components with a constant spacing.
g = gf.grid(sweep)
g.plot()
gh = gf.grid(sweep, shape=(1, len(sweep)))
gh.plot()
gh_ymin = gf.grid(sweep, shape=(len(sweep), 1), align_x="xmin")
gh_ymin.plot()
You can also add text labels to each element of the sweep
gh_ymin = gf.grid_with_text(
sweep, shape=(len(sweep), 1), align_x="xmax", text=text_metal
)
gh_ymin.plot()
gh_ymin = gf.grid_with_text(
sweep,
shape=(len(sweep), 1),
align_x="xmax",
text=text_metal,
labels=["S100", "S200", "S300"],
)
gh_ymin.plot()
You have 2 ways of defining a mask:
in YAML
in Python
YAML Component#
You can also define your Component in YAML format thanks to gdsfactory.read.from_yaml
You need to define:
instances
placements
routes (optional)
and you can leverage:
pack_doe
pack_doe_grid
pack_doe
places components as compact as possible.
c = gf.read.from_yaml(
"""
name: mask_grid
instances:
rings:
component: pack_doe
settings:
doe: ring_single
settings:
radius: [30, 50, 20, 40]
length_x: [1, 2, 3]
do_permutations: True
function:
function: add_fiber_array
settings:
fanout_length: 200
mzis:
component: pack_doe
settings:
doe: mzi
settings:
delta_length: [10, 100]
function: add_fiber_array
placements:
rings:
xmin: 50
mzis:
xmin: rings,east
"""
)
c.show()
c.plot()
pack_doe_grid
places each component on a regular grid
c = gf.read.from_yaml(
"""
name: mask_compact
instances:
rings:
component: pack_doe
settings:
doe: ring_single
settings:
radius: [30, 50, 20, 40]
length_x: [1, 2, 3]
do_permutations: True
function:
function: add_fiber_array
settings:
fanout_length: 200
mzis:
component: pack_doe_grid
settings:
doe: mzi
settings:
delta_length: [10, 100]
do_permutations: True
spacing: [10, 10]
function: add_fiber_array
placements:
rings:
xmin: 50
mzis:
xmin: rings,east
"""
)
c.show()
c.plot()
Automated testing and analysis#
This is useful when you have a lot of components and you want to automate the testing process.
There are two main ways to define which components are testable:
Include a
doe
(Design of Experiments) field in the component.info dictionary, as well as all relevant test and analysis information.Include a GDS label in all component test points. There are many ways to define test points, but the most common is to use a GDS label with the format
<elec/opt>-<number_of_ports>-<cell_name>
. This way you can easily extract all test points from the GDS file.
import pandas as pd
import gdsfactory as gf
@gf.cell
def mzm_gc(length_x=10, **kwargs) -> gf.Component:
"""Returns a MZI with Grating Couplers.
Args:
length_x: length of the MZI.
kwargs: additional settings.
"""
c = gf.components.mzi2x2_2x2_phase_shifter(
length_x=length_x, auto_rename_ports=False, **kwargs
)
c = gf.routing.add_pads_top(c, port_names=["top_l_e1", "top_r_e3"])
c = gf.routing.add_fiber_array(c)
c.info["doe"] = "mzm"
c.info["measurement"] = "optical_spectrum"
c.info["analysis"] = "[fsr]"
c.info["analysis_parameters"] = "[]"
c.info["ports_electrical"] = 2
c.info["ports_optical"] = 6
c.info["length_x"] = length_x
c.info.update(kwargs)
return c
def sample_reticle(grid: bool = False) -> gf.Component:
"""Returns MZI with TE grating couplers."""
from gdsfactory.generic_tech.cells import (
add_fiber_array_optical_south_electrical_north,
)
mzis = [mzm_gc(length_x=lengths) for lengths in [100, 200, 300]]
spirals = [spiral_gc(length=length) for length in [0, 100, 200]]
rings = []
for length_x in [10, 20, 30]:
ring = gf.components.ring_single_heater(length_x=length_x)
c = add_fiber_array_optical_south_electrical_north(
component=ring,
electrical_port_names=["l_e2", "r_e2"],
)
c.name = f"ring_{length_x}"
c.info["doe"] = "ring_length_x"
c.info["measurement"] = "optical_spectrum"
c.info["ports_electrical"] = 2
c.info["ports_optical"] = 4
c.info["analysis"] = "[fsr]"
c.info["analysis_parameters"] = "[]"
c.info["length_x"] = length_x
rings.append(c)
copies = 3 # number of copies of each component
components = mzis * copies + rings * copies + spirals * copies
if grid:
return gf.grid(components)
c = gf.pack(components)
if len(c) > 1:
c = gf.pack(c)[0]
return c[0]
c = sample_reticle()
c.show()
c
gf.labels.write_test_manifest(c, csvpath="sample_reticle.csv")
df = pd.read_csv("sample_reticle.csv")
df
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'mzm_gc_LX100'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'mzm_gc_LX200'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'mzm_gc_LX300'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'mzm_gc_LX100'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'mzm_gc_LX200'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'mzm_gc_LX300'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'mzm_gc_LX100'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'mzm_gc_LX200'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'mzm_gc_LX300'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'ring_10'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'ring_20'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'ring_30'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'ring_10'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'ring_20'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'ring_30'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'ring_10'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'ring_20'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'ring_30'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'spiral_gc_L200'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'spiral_gc_L200'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'spiral_gc_L200'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'spiral_gc_L100'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'spiral_gc_L100'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'spiral_gc_L100'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'spiral_gc_L0'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'spiral_gc_L0'
Warning: 'measurement_parameters' missing from 'spiral_gc_L0'
cell | x | y | info | ports | settings | doe | analysis | analysis_parameters | measurement | measurement_parameters | ports_optical | ports_electrical | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0 | mzm_gc_LX100 | 250.020 | 153.225 | {"length_x": 100} | {"in_o1": {"name": "in_o1", "center": [145.02,... | {"length_x":100} | mzm | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 6 | 2 |
1 | mzm_gc_LX200 | 200.020 | 419.775 | {"length_x": 200} | {"in_o1": {"name": "in_o1", "center": [145.02,... | {"length_x":200} | mzm | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 6 | 2 |
2 | mzm_gc_LX300 | 150.020 | 686.325 | {"length_x": 300} | {"in_o1": {"name": "in_o1", "center": [145.02,... | {"length_x":300} | mzm | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 6 | 2 |
3 | mzm_gc_LX100 | 250.020 | 952.876 | {"length_x": 100} | {"in_o1": {"name": "in_o1", "center": [145.02,... | {"length_x":100} | mzm | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 6 | 2 |
4 | mzm_gc_LX200 | 200.020 | 1219.426 | {"length_x": 200} | {"in_o1": {"name": "in_o1", "center": [145.02,... | {"length_x":200} | mzm | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 6 | 2 |
5 | mzm_gc_LX300 | 150.020 | 1485.976 | {"length_x": 300} | {"in_o1": {"name": "in_o1", "center": [145.02,... | {"length_x":300} | mzm | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 6 | 2 |
6 | mzm_gc_LX100 | 250.020 | 1752.526 | {"length_x": 100} | {"in_o1": {"name": "in_o1", "center": [145.02,... | {"length_x":100} | mzm | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 6 | 2 |
7 | mzm_gc_LX200 | 200.020 | 2019.076 | {"length_x": 200} | {"in_o1": {"name": "in_o1", "center": [145.02,... | {"length_x":200} | mzm | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 6 | 2 |
8 | mzm_gc_LX300 | 820.960 | 153.225 | {"length_x": 300} | {"in_o1": {"name": "in_o1", "center": [815.96,... | {"length_x":300} | mzm | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 6 | 2 |
9 | ring_10 | 884.460 | 367.151 | {"length_x": 10} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [815.96, 300.6... | {} | ring_length_x | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 2 |
10 | ring_20 | 889.460 | 707.151 | {"length_x": 20} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [815.96, 640.6... | {} | ring_length_x | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 2 |
11 | ring_30 | 894.460 | 1047.151 | {"length_x": 30} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [815.96, 980.6... | {} | ring_length_x | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 2 |
12 | ring_10 | 884.460 | 1387.151 | {"length_x": 10} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [815.96, 1320.... | {} | ring_length_x | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 2 |
13 | ring_20 | 889.460 | 1727.151 | {"length_x": 20} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [815.96, 1660.... | {} | ring_length_x | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 2 |
14 | ring_30 | 1311.400 | 367.151 | {"length_x": 30} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [1232.9, 300.6... | {} | ring_length_x | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 2 |
15 | ring_10 | 1301.400 | 707.151 | {"length_x": 10} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [1232.9, 640.6... | {} | ring_length_x | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 2 |
16 | ring_20 | 1306.400 | 1047.151 | {"length_x": 20} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [1232.9, 980.6... | {} | ring_length_x | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 2 |
17 | ring_30 | 1311.400 | 1387.151 | {"length_x": 30} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [1232.9, 1320.... | {} | ring_length_x | [fsr] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 2 |
18 | spiral_gc_L200 | 1395.179 | 140.351 | {"length": 200} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [1551.179, 34.... | {"length":200} | spirals_sc | [power_envelope] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 0 |
19 | spiral_gc_L200 | 1141.179 | 1766.901 | {"length": 200} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [1297.179, 166... | {"length":200} | spirals_sc | [power_envelope] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 0 |
20 | spiral_gc_L200 | 1141.179 | 1950.451 | {"length": 200} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [1297.179, 184... | {"length":200} | spirals_sc | [power_envelope] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 0 |
21 | spiral_gc_L100 | 759.960 | 2106.901 | {"length": 100} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [815.96, 2000.... | {"length":100} | spirals_sc | [power_envelope] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 0 |
22 | spiral_gc_L100 | 1593.840 | 323.901 | {"length": 100} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [1649.84000000... | {"length":100} | spirals_sc | [power_envelope] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 0 |
23 | spiral_gc_L100 | 1593.840 | 507.451 | {"length": 100} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [1649.84000000... | {"length":100} | spirals_sc | [power_envelope] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 0 |
24 | spiral_gc_L0 | 1693.840 | 680.751 | {"length": 0} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [1649.84000000... | {"length":0} | spirals_sc | [power_envelope] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 0 |
25 | spiral_gc_L0 | 1693.840 | 854.051 | {"length": 0} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [1649.84000000... | {"length":0} | spirals_sc | [power_envelope] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 0 |
26 | spiral_gc_L0 | 1693.840 | 1027.351 | {"length": 0} | {"o1": {"name": "o1", "center": [1649.84000000... | {"length":0} | spirals_sc | [power_envelope] | [] | optical_spectrum | NaN | 4 | 0 |
You can see a test manifest example here
Automated testing with labels#
The GDS info is stored in the GDS file metadata and can be lost if the GDS file is modified with other tools that are not aware of the metadata. To avoid this, GDSFactory also supports a more traditional way of defining test points, using GDS labels.
For example, lets say you want to label the rightmost port of a component with a GDS label port_type-number_of_ports-cell_name
. You can do this with the following code:
import gdsfactory as gf
from gdsfactory.typings import LayerSpec
layer_label = "TEXT"
def label_farthest_right_port(
component: gf.Component, ports: gf.Port | list[gf.Port], layer: LayerSpec, text: str
) -> gf.Component:
"""Adds a label to the right of the farthest right port in a given component.
Args:
component: The component to which the label is added.
ports: A list of ports to evaluate for positioning the label.
layer: The layer on which the label will be added.
text: The text to display in the label.
"""
rightmost_port = max(ports, key=lambda port: port.dx)
component.add_label(
text=text,
position=rightmost_port.dcenter,
layer=layer,
)
return component
c = gf.Component()
ref = c << gf.routing.add_pads_top(gf.components.wire_straight())
label_farthest_right_port(c, ref.ports, layer=layer_label, text="elec-2-wire_straight")
c
def spiral_gc(length: float = 0, **kwargs) -> gf.Component:
"""Returns a spiral double with Grating Couplers.
Args:
length: length of the spiral straight section.
kwargs: additional settings.
Keyword Args:
bend: bend component.
straight: straight component.
cross_section: cross_section component.
spacing: spacing between the spiral loops.
n_loops: number of loops.
"""
c0 = gf.c.spiral(length=length, **kwargs)
c = gf.routing.add_fiber_array(c0)
c.info["doe"] = "spirals_sc"
c.info["measurement"] = "optical_spectrum"
c.info["analysis"] = "[power_envelope]"
c.info["analysis_parameters"] = "[]"
c.info["ports_optical"] = 4
c.info["ports_electrical"] = 0
c.info.update(kwargs)
c.name = f"spiral_gc_{length}"
label_farthest_right_port(c, c.ports, layer=layer_label, text=f"opt-4-{c.name}")
return c
c = spiral_gc(length=0)
c
def mzi_gc(length_x=10, **kwargs) -> gf.Component:
"""Returns a MZI with Grating Couplers.
Args:
length_x: length of the MZI.
kwargs: additional settings.
"""
c = gf.components.mzi2x2_2x2_phase_shifter(
length_x=length_x, auto_rename_ports=False, **kwargs
)
c = gf.routing.add_pads_top(c, port_names=("top_l_e1", "top_r_e3"))
c.name = f"mzi_{length_x}"
c = gf.routing.add_fiber_array(c)
c.info["doe"] = "mzi"
c.info["measurement"] = "optical_spectrum"
c.info["analysis"] = "[fsr]"
c.info["analysis_parameters"] = "[]"
c.info["ports_electrical"] = 2
c.info["ports_optical"] = 6
c.info["length_x"] = length_x
c.info.update(kwargs)
c.name = f"mzi_gc_{length_x}"
label_farthest_right_port(
c,
c.ports.filter(port_type="vertical_te"),
layer=layer_label,
text=f"opt-{c.info['ports_optical']}-{c.name}",
)
label_farthest_right_port(
c,
c.ports.filter(port_type="electrical"),
layer=layer_label,
text=f"elec-{c.info['ports_electrical']}-{c.name}",
)
return c
c = mzi_gc(length_x=10)
c
def sample_reticle_with_labels(grid: bool = False) -> gf.Component:
"""Returns MZI with TE grating couplers."""
from gdsfactory.generic_tech.cells import (
add_fiber_array_optical_south_electrical_north,
)
mzis = [mzi_gc(length_x=lengths) for lengths in [100, 200, 300]]
spirals = [spiral_gc(length=length) for length in [0, 100, 200]]
rings = []
for length_x in [10, 20, 30]:
ring = gf.components.ring_single_heater(length_x=length_x)
c = add_fiber_array_optical_south_electrical_north(
component=ring,
electrical_port_names=["l_e2", "r_e2"],
)
c.name = f"ring_{length_x}"
c.info["doe"] = "ring_length_x"
c.info["measurement"] = "optical_spectrum"
c.info["ports_electrical"] = 2
c.info["ports_optical"] = 4
c.info["analysis"] = "[fsr]"
c.info["analysis_parameters"] = "[]"
label_farthest_right_port(
c,
c.ports.filter(port_type="vertical_te"),
layer=layer_label,
text=f"opt-{c.info['ports_optical']}-{c.name}",
)
label_farthest_right_port(
c,
c.ports.filter(port_type="electrical"),
layer=layer_label,
text=f"elec-{c.info['ports_electrical']}-{c.name}",
)
rings.append(c)
copies = 3 # number of copies of each component
components = mzis * copies + rings * copies + spirals * copies
if grid:
return gf.grid(components)
c = gf.pack(components)
if len(c) > 1:
c = gf.pack(c)[0]
return c[0]
c = sample_reticle_with_labels()
c
You can also extract all test points from a GDS file using gf.labels.write_labels
import pandas as pd
gdspath = c.write_gds()
csvpath = gf.labels.write_labels(gdspath, layer_label=layer_label)
df = pd.read_csv(csvpath)
df = df.sort_values(by=["text"])
df
text | x | y | angle | |
---|---|---|---|---|
13 | elec-2-mzi_gc_100 | 395.920 | 1724.401 | 0.0 |
1 | elec-2-mzi_gc_100 | 395.920 | 125.100 | 0.0 |
7 | elec-2-mzi_gc_100 | 395.920 | 924.751 | 0.0 |
3 | elec-2-mzi_gc_200 | 445.920 | 391.650 | 0.0 |
9 | elec-2-mzi_gc_200 | 445.920 | 1191.301 | 0.0 |
15 | elec-2-mzi_gc_200 | 445.920 | 1990.951 | 0.0 |
5 | elec-2-mzi_gc_300 | 495.920 | 658.200 | 0.0 |
17 | elec-2-mzi_gc_300 | 1166.860 | 125.100 | 0.0 |
11 | elec-2-mzi_gc_300 | 495.920 | 1457.851 | 0.0 |
25 | elec-2-ring_10 | 929.460 | 1541.600 | 0.0 |
19 | elec-2-ring_10 | 929.460 | 521.600 | 0.0 |
31 | elec-2-ring_10 | 1346.400 | 861.600 | 0.0 |
21 | elec-2-ring_20 | 929.460 | 861.600 | 0.0 |
27 | elec-2-ring_20 | 929.460 | 1881.600 | 0.0 |
33 | elec-2-ring_20 | 1346.400 | 1201.600 | 0.0 |
29 | elec-2-ring_30 | 1346.400 | 521.600 | 0.0 |
35 | elec-2-ring_30 | 1346.400 | 1541.600 | 0.0 |
23 | elec-2-ring_30 | 929.460 | 1201.600 | 0.0 |
30 | opt-4-ring_10 | 1486.900 | 640.661 | 0.0 |
18 | opt-4-ring_10 | 1069.960 | 300.661 | 0.0 |
24 | opt-4-ring_10 | 1069.960 | 1320.661 | 0.0 |
32 | opt-4-ring_20 | 1486.900 | 980.661 | 0.0 |
20 | opt-4-ring_20 | 1069.960 | 640.661 | 0.0 |
26 | opt-4-ring_20 | 1069.960 | 1660.661 | 0.0 |
34 | opt-4-ring_30 | 1486.900 | 1320.661 | 0.0 |
28 | opt-4-ring_30 | 1486.900 | 300.661 | 0.0 |
22 | opt-4-ring_30 | 1069.960 | 980.661 | 0.0 |
42 | opt-4-spiral_gc_0 | 1903.840 | 584.761 | 0.0 |
44 | opt-4-spiral_gc_0 | 1903.840 | 931.361 | 0.0 |
43 | opt-4-spiral_gc_0 | 1903.840 | 758.061 | 0.0 |
39 | opt-4-spiral_gc_100 | 1069.960 | 2000.661 | 0.0 |
40 | opt-4-spiral_gc_100 | 1903.840 | 217.661 | 0.0 |
41 | opt-4-spiral_gc_100 | 1903.840 | 401.211 | 0.0 |
36 | opt-4-spiral_gc_200 | 1805.179 | 34.111 | 0.0 |
37 | opt-4-spiral_gc_200 | 1551.179 | 1660.661 | 0.0 |
38 | opt-4-spiral_gc_200 | 1551.179 | 1844.211 | 0.0 |
12 | opt-6-mzi_gc_100 | 653.020 | 1633.411 | 0.0 |
6 | opt-6-mzi_gc_100 | 653.020 | 833.761 | 0.0 |
0 | opt-6-mzi_gc_100 | 653.020 | 34.110 | 0.0 |
14 | opt-6-mzi_gc_200 | 653.020 | 1899.961 | 0.0 |
8 | opt-6-mzi_gc_200 | 653.020 | 1100.311 | 0.0 |
2 | opt-6-mzi_gc_200 | 653.020 | 300.660 | 0.0 |
16 | opt-6-mzi_gc_300 | 1323.960 | 34.110 | 0.0 |
10 | opt-6-mzi_gc_300 | 653.020 | 1366.861 | 0.0 |
4 | opt-6-mzi_gc_300 | 653.020 | 567.210 | 0.0 |